Robert R. Reilly

recent articles

Music: Lady Macbeth and the Population Problem

On a recent tour through Europe, I made opera stops in Paris and London to see Lucia di Lammermoor by Doni­zetti (1797-1848) and Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk by Shostakovich (1906-1975). However, my first destination was Ljubljana, Slovenia, for a non-musical conference. There, I was told that 13 Slovenes die each day, while only nine are … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: Christmas Comes But Once A Year

The famous Christmas carol goes, “Adeste fideles, laeti tri­umphantes.” The translation reads, “O come, all ye faithful, joyful and triumphant.” The Latin is more succinct: “Come, be present, happy, triumphant.” The carol continues, “come”, then repeats, “venite.” Few refrains are more haunting. But “be present where?” we wonder. The answer comes: “Venite, venite in Beth­lehem.” … Read more

The Pope and the Prophet

Finally, a leader has spoken about the real, essential lam, as it emanates from a contest within Islam itself over the most important things. With startling—indeed alarming—clarity, Pope Benedict XVI told his audience in Regensburg, Germany, that not only is violence in spread­ing faith unreasonable and therefore against God, but that a conception of God … Read more

Music: Charles Koechlin—‘Alchemist of Sound’

In the latter half of the 19th century, German music so dominated the European continent that the French were left wondering what could be distinctively theirs, aside from French insouciance, wit, and whimsy. France could not com­pete in the symphony (Beethoven, Brahms, Bruckner, etc.), and Wagner had swamped the opera world. Erik Satie (1866-1925) came … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: On Changing One Letter

When asked to write a col­umn in the Georgetown student newspaper, I requested the editor not to change a submitted word without my permis­sion. This concern results from long experience. Your finest word turns out, in print, to be “blah” because some editor knew better than you, the writer, what you should have said. The … Read more

Music: Hello Out There

For twelve years I have been composing this column. Sometimes I wonder if many people read it. Then I remember that I have seldom, if ever, written to columnists I regularly read. So why should anyone write to me? During my broadcasting career, I suffered similar doubts when I was on the air daily to … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: Unexpected Kindnesses

The pastor of the Anglican parish in Georgetown, Rev. Charles Nalls, suggested lunch. I proposed Billy Martin’s, about halfway between his parish and the university. We both wore Roman collars, both arrived on time. The restaurant was not crowded after the noontime rush. We talked of things ecclesiastical and otherwise. No one was in a … Read more

The King’s Anguish: Mistranslating the Holy Scriptures

“If any man,” says the preacher, “can show just cause why they may not lawfully be joined together, let him now speak, or else hereafter forever hold his peace.” At that the door is flung open, and in strides anybody from a dozen old movies. The screen­writers knew their trade. The one marriage service from … Read more

Music: Getting The Requiem Right

There are all sorts of ways to get the Requiem wrong, as illustrated by a number of new releases of musical settings of this venerable text, and ways to get it right also, as some other superb new CDs show. The same is true of the Stabat Mater. The works I deal with here were … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: “The Power of Great Minds”

What is peculiar to Catholi­cism is that, while it is a religion of intellect, it is also concerned with the salvation of lesser luminaries, of ordinary folks. The aborted fetus has the same tran­scendent destiny as the greatest phi­losopher or the greatest sinner. Indeed, the greatest philosopher and the great­est sinner may be, to recall … Read more

Mary, Queen of Theologians

Into the face that most resembles Christ now look: for by her radiance only she can render you prepared for seeing Christ. (Paradiso 32.85-87) So says St. Bernard to the pilgrim Dante, urging him to gaze into the countenance of Mary, as they stand at the threshold of the Beatific Vision. They are words I have … Read more

Music: Summer

Bruckner at the beach? I don’t think so. Sand and high seri­ousness are strange bedfellows. So let us construct the aural equivalent of the summer reading list based upon music that is amiable, off the beaten path, and, well, fun. I happen to have a huge inventory of CD recommenda­tions that fits the bill. The … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: The Political Philosophy of Aquinas

Thomas Aquinas put things succinctly. He found num­berless things about which to think. He could, with few words, illuminate the whole of what is in logi­cal form. He wrote little about politi­cal things. He discussed other topics normally called “political”—property, rebellion, prudence, justice, virtue, and common good. In commenting on the Gospels of Matthew and … Read more

Music: Lost in America

Last January, I promised to cover more releases of Ameri­can music as a rebuke to the noxious thesis that our only culture is agriculture—or, even worse, pop cul­ture. But who would know about these riches, and how? They have received very little exposure, and now get even less. Every weekday, National Public Radio used to … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: What Belongs to the Wise Man

Book one, chapter one, of Aquinas’s Summa Contra Gentiles, concerning wisdom, begins by citing Proverbs: “My mouth shall meditate truth, and my lips shall hate iniquity” (8:7). Aquinas finds two sides to this statement. The first is “to medi­tate and speak forth of the divine truth which is truth in person”; the second, “to refute … Read more

Music: Leaving Home

Arthaus Musik, distributed by Naxos, has released an in­triguing series of seven DVDs titled Leaving Home: Orchestral Music in the 20th Century. Created for a TV con­sortium in 1996, Leaving Home features conductor Sir Simon Rattle and the City of Birmingham Symphony Or­chestra on a tour through some of the significant musical landmarks of the … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: Truth as Reality

On February 10, 2006, Pope Benedict XVI received his old Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith colleagues. The pope here broached the noblest issues of our kind. Many things were suc­cinctly put together that are not often put together, succinctly or otherwise. “Faith has a fundamental importance in the life of the Church, because … Read more

Kneeling Before the Gates of Paradise

What wonders we American Catholics have seen. Schools, whose joists were sawn and spiked by the hands of men who would send their children there, now empty, crumbling; whole orders of nuns doffing their habits, then their faith and reason too, worthy societies dwindling into a few old men with beers and a shuffleboard table, … Read more

Music: ReiIly auf Naxos

Gramophone/FM Classic awarded Naxos the classical label of the year award in 2005. Based on the evidence so far, I am prepared to concede the award to Naxos in 2006. I am supplied monthly with a list of releases from Naxos and from its distributed labels—such as CPO, Profil, and Marco Polo—that is simply staggering … Read more

Sense and Nonsense: God’s Governance

Men are subject to subtle temptations. The most dangerous of these temptations suggests that, by our own power and ingenuity, we can both identify the root problem causing human ills and eliminate it. At bottom, it is a technical, rather than a personal problem. We can solve it without solving the question of our souls. … Read more

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00