American Thanksgiving is a week away. Here in Canada, we celebrated ours about a month and a half earlier, on October 12. At the time, I was visiting my parents in Spain, where on the same day they celebrate their National Day, which is similar to Columbus Day in the United States, marking Columbus’ arrival in the Americas.
This time of year always reminds me of John Hughes’ 1987 dramatic comedy Planes, Trains, and Automobiles. Over the years, I’ve come to reflect more and more deeply on the chance encounter at its heart. Essentially, I believe the thrust of the movie is about what it means to give thanks, to offer kindness, and to receive another person’s kindness with humility.
First, there is Neal Page (Steve Martin), who wants nothing more than to get home to his family for Thanksgiving, and second, Del Griffith (John Candy), who sells shower curtain rings and whom Neal can’t seem to shake. The more that Neal tries to return home, the less patient he becomes toward Del.
Anyone who has struggled to come home for a holiday can relate to Neal’s plight. For those who haven’t seen the movie, Del’s endless chatter and seemingly pointless ramblings are a source of great comic relief but become extremely tiresome for Neal. In one scene, the two men are forced to share a motel room—and one small bed, though Del is a much larger man—and are robbed in the middle of the night. Before all that, Neal bursts out in frustration, letting Del know how annoying he finds him by stating, “Here’s a good idea: have a point. It makes it so much more interesting for the listener!” What initially starts as a funny outburst turns into a scene that is rather painful to watch. Del then admits that he talks too much but then adds, “I like… I like me. My wife likes me.” The pause before saying it shows how deeply Neal’s words wound Del. (These words gave Colin Hanks’ documentary its title: John Candy: I Like Me.)
Essentially, I believe the thrust of the movie is about what it means to give thanks, to offer kindness, and to receive another person’s kindness with humility.Tweet ThisI have always been able to identify with both men in this scene. I think it’s a demonstration of how real their portrayal is. When I think someone is rambling, I usually hold my tongue, but I sometimes indulge in the fantasy of saying something as harsh as what Neal says, or worse. St. Thomas Aquinas says that meekness “moderates anger according to right reason” (Summa Theologiae, II–II, q. 157, a. 2). Even though I may not say it aloud, I sometimes still rehearse the remark in my head.
Pope Benedict XVI, in Deus Caritas Est, explains how a deep encounter with God can make it possible to love someone we dislike or barely know: “in God and with God, I love even the person whom I do not like or even know” (§18). One can see this manifest itself when Neal, on the train home, begins to reflect on all the things Del had told him. This prompts him to go back to the train station to find Del. This is where Del reveals that his wife, Marie, had died eight years earlier and that he has no home to return to. This lends all the more poignancy to his words: “My wife likes me.” He speaks of her love in the present tense. Neal invites him to spend Thanksgiving with his family. Such an encounter with God can transform how we view another person. Neal’s change of heart gives us a theatrical glimpse of how that can look. After trying so hard to get home, he turns back to get Del, so that he doesn’t have to spend Thanksgiving alone.
After trying so hard to get home, he turns back to get Del, so that he doesn’t have to spend Thanksgiving alone.Tweet ThisI believe it is worth recognizing that there is true humility in receiving, too. Neal spends much of the trip depending on a man he would never choose as a companion. And Del, who masks his deep suffering with humor, has to wait for Neal to realize how truly alone he is and in turn has to accept his invitation. It can be a humbling experience to sometimes acknowledge that you are in desperate need of love and charity. A person can offer a meal, an apology, or a renewed friendship, but the other person must remain free to receive or reject what is offered. That freedom matters because the gift is an expression of love, and love must always be freely given, and the other person must be free to accept or decline it. This is symbolized by the walk to Neal’s house and up to his front door, where the two men carry Del’s trunk together. (As an aside, one can’t help but wonder about this mysterious trunk of a man who sells shower curtain rings and claims to have no home—it’s strangely heavy. Dark-humor speculations of this kind have been circulating for years.)
Neal invites Del to Thanksgiving dinner without expecting anything in return. In Luke’s Gospel, Jesus asks his host to invite people who cannot repay him (Luke 14:12–14). We can give thanks for what we ourselves have received, beginning with the mercy of God, by making a call we’ve put off, accepting an invitation we’d usually decline, or setting another place at dinner. There is also the person we think to invite on Thanksgiving who may still be eating alone the following week. We can still extend an invitation to them at times other than Thanksgiving or Christmas, and to paraphrase George Michael in his song “Praying for Time”: charity should not be a coat we wear only twice a year.
This makes me think precisely of Del standing at the door, holding his hat as “Every Time You Go Away” plays in the background. The song makes the moment all the more moving. We now know who’s missing from Del’s life, and we see what it means to him to be welcomed into Neal’s home. Neal has brought him home, and Del has said yes. Even though Thanksgiving is only one day, the mercy we receive from God is not. The same door that was opened for Del on that Thursday in 1987 is a door we should keep open for the rest of the year, especially when the music has died and the holiday has passed.
There are no comments yet.