Counting the Damned

Yes, there is a Hell, but no one knows what human beings are in it. Which leaves us free—indeed, obliged—to hope that, please God, it won’t be nearly as crowded as some may have predicted.

PUBLISHED ON

November 20, 2026

How many souls are there in Hell? Is there a list of names somewhere of who these people are? After all, if Mother Church can keep track of her children in Heaven, it stands to reason she knows who the sinners are in Hell.

Do we really know? I ask because I’ve got some skin in this game and so I’d very much like to find out. At my doctoral defense in Rome, for instance, I remember standing before an audience of learned professors asking me all sorts of questions about Hell. Yet despite my having just written a dissertation on the subject, not a single professor evinced the least interest in knowing either the names or the numbers of the damned.

I thought that a bit odd at the time, especially after having answered all the other questions put to me. Except one, that is. An older professor, rather irascible as I recall, wanted to know why there were so many footnotes from Hans Urs von Balthasar throughout my text. Was it really necessary, he asked somewhat petulantly, to insert all that Balthasar stuff into my book? “It’s not as if he were a Cardinal or anything,” he complained.

Soon after letting him know that I had no earthly idea, the interrogation came to an end, after which I got my degree and left town. It was only on the train the next day that I heard the news that Hans Urs von Balthasar had just been made a cardinal. Of course, he never got to wear the red hat, having died the morning of his flight to Rome, where Pope John Paul II was waiting to put it on. I’d have given anything to see the face of that professor when he got the news.

It was only on the train the next day that I heard the news that Hans Urs von Balthasar had just been made a cardinal.Tweet This

So, what does the Church know about the lost souls? And why won’t she share what she knows? The answer is that she doesn’t know anything more about the subject than I do. No one knows. Yes, there is a Hell, and we know with absolute moral certainty that the fallen angels are there, but not that any human beings are. Which leaves us free to hope that, please God, it won’t be nearly as crowded as some may have predicted.

That fiery North African of the second century named Tertullian, for example, who so looked forward to seeing from the heights of Heaven all the souls of the wicked writhing in Hell. What a setback if he were to discover that there might not be quite so many, or that, God forbid, he’d be one of them!

How did Blessed Fulton Sheen put it? That there may be three surprises waiting for him on the Other Side: One, that many of those he expected to see there, alas, had not made it. Two, that many he never expected to see there, actually did make it. And, three, the most surprising discovery of all, that he had in fact made it.

Again, we do not know, only that we are free to hope. Indeed, we are obliged to hope. And not just for ourselves, or those closest to us. But for everyone. What else does it mean to love if not to hope for all those whom we are required to love? “Too often we think of hope in too individualistic a manner as merely our own salvation,” writes Jean Daniélou, future cardinal of the Catholic Church. “But hope essentially bears on the great actions of God concerning the whole of creation. It bears on the destiny of all humanity. It is the salvation of the world that we await. In reality hope bears on the salvation of all men—and it is only in the measure that I am immersed in them that it bears on me.”

What else does it mean to love if not to hope for all those whom we are required to love?Tweet This

So, what is the official teaching of the Church? Well, take a look at the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which first appeared in October 1992, thirty years to the day following the opening of the Second Vatican Council, and you’ll find out. Articles 1033 to 1037 are perfectly straightforward on the subject. What is Hell? It is defined as “a state of definitive self-exclusion from communion with God and the blessed.” An eternity of sheer self-inflicted torment, in other words, which can only be the result of the sinner’s obdurate refusal to accept Christ’s offer of salvation. It is when the soul, determined on a path of complete rejection of God, says to God in a final and irrevocable way: “I don’t want to love. I don’t want to be loved. I just want to be left alone. Forever.”

And God, of course, having paid us the highest possible compliment of taking our freedom seriously, will not prevent its exercise even at the expense of our everlasting misery. “All that are in Hell,” declares C.S. Lewis, “choose it. Without that self-choice there could be no Hell.” Everything depends, therefore, on whether it is God or the self who says, “Thy will be done.” If it is I who say it to God, then all at once I am welcomed into the Precincts of Unending Felicity. However, if the sentence is pronounced by God, then it is I who sink under the sheer weight of my own self-centered self, falling ineluctably into the mire and the misery of Hell. In the end, therefore, the creature gets exactly what it wants, indeed, what it has long since sought and organized its life around. If life, to quote the poet Keats, “is a vale of soul making,” then it will have been either Heaven or Hell that the soul has most sedulously sought to make for itself. Once made, of course, there will be no time to apply finishing touches.

“God predestines no one to go to Hell,” says the Catechism, citing a couple of early church councils to certify the claim. Then quoting the most ancient Eucharistic Prayer, the Church enjoins God himself no less, “to order our days in your peace, and command that we be delivered from eternal damnation and counted among the flock of those you have chosen.”

What further evidence do we require that it is not God who condemns us, even less that he should take pleasure in sending anyone to Hell? “The silence of the Church,” says Pope John Paul II in Crossing the Threshold of Hope, “is, therefore, the only appropriate position for Christian faith. Even when Jesus says of Judas, the traitor, ‘It would be better for that man if he had never been born’ (Mt 26:24), his words do not allude for certain to eternal damnation.” Let us not forget that it was Jesus himself who undid the damage caused by Adam’s sin—abetted, to be sure, by the trickery of the devil—thus saving the entire human race thanks to the perfect sacrifice of Christ upon the Cross. It necessarily follows that the grace of redemption aims to reach everyone. Only those who perversely refuse the invitation to spend an eternity in his company, burning every last bridge to beatitude, will freely take themselves into the bowels of Hell. Slamming shut the door that leads therein, to recall that most telling and instructive detail from the famous Holman Hunt painting of Jesus gently rapping on the door of the soul. Which is that only from the inside can it be opened, owing to the fact that there is no handle on the outside.

“The only hope, or else despair,” T.S. Eliot reminds us in a sublime passage from Four Quartets,

Lies in the choice of pyre or pyre—
To be redeemed from fire by fire.

“Who then devised the torment?” he asks. “Love,” he answers, “is the unfamiliar Name / Behind the hands that wove / The intolerable shirt of flame / Which human power cannot remove.

We only live, only suspire
Consumed by either fire or fire.”

And God, of course, having paid us the highest possible compliment of taking our freedom seriously, will not prevent its exercise even at the expense of our everlasting misery.Tweet This

The implication is perfectly plain, which is that we are free to endure either the fire of Divine Love, whose blazing Pentecostal descent inspires us to turn to God and neighbor; or else we turn to the devouring fire of the self-centered self, feeding on its own sins, which sooner or later set the soul on fire forever, consumed by its own self-willed rejection of God.

We are not thrown by God into that sea of fire. It is our own sins that fill that sea, each a seething cauldron of self-imposed enmity and pain. “At a certain point,” writes Origen, the great Church Father of the third century, “in a soul that has accumulated all sorts of evil deeds and sins, this mixture catches fire and begins, in punishment of the soul, to burn…it will be its own accuser and witness.”

God is not to blame; indeed, he went all the way to the Cross, and beyond—into the deepest mystery of all, that of Holy Saturday—to prove his innocence, to the extent even of taking on the sin of the world in order to burn it all up in the fire of a far greater love. “For us,” says Eliot,

there is only the trying. The rest is not our business.

Author

  • Regis Martin

    Regis Martin is Professor of Theology and Faculty Associate with the Veritas Center for Ethics in Public Life at the Franciscan University of Steubenville. He earned a licentiate and a doctorate in sacred theology from the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas in Rome. Martin is the author of a number of books, including Still Point: Loss, Longing, and Our Search for God (2012) and The Beggar's Banquet (Emmaus Road). His most recent book, published by Sophia Institute Press, is March to Martyrdom: Seven Letters on Sanctity from St. Ignatius of Antioch.

Orthodox. Faithful. Free.

Sign up to get Crisis articles delivered to your inbox daily

Email subscribe inline (#4)

Join the Conversation

Comments are a benefit for financial supporters of Crisis. If you are a monthly or annual supporter, please login to comment. A Crisis account has been created for you using the email address you used to donate.

Donate

There are no comments yet.

Editor's picks

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00
Share to...