On Nov. 5, G2 Esports fired one of its League of Legends coaches, Luka Perkovic, after he made a long X post stating that he is a devout Catholic and thus believes that abortion is murder.
Not knowing anything else about either party involved, I couldn’t help but come away from that news story with one question in mind: if he had simply said, “I am Catholic and therefore pro-life,” would the reaction have been the same? To be sure, there would still have been backlash, but it’s hard to believe he’d have been fired. Whatever the term “pro-life” originally meant, today it means something different than “abortion is murder.”
The obvious reason for this is that “abortion is murder” implies a murderer. “Pro-life,” on the other hand, simply conveys a respect for life in general. “Abortion is murder” refers to a fundamental societal problem. Yes, a political issue—but much more. A profound issue of justice; a sin that cries out to heaven. “I’m pro-life” is a stance on public policy. Maybe something you think about every few years in November, but not the gut-wrenching reality of a million murdered babies every year.
To be extremely clear, I am confident that most people who identify as pro-life do know the gravity of the problem, especially if they are Christian. It is because Christians always have been and always will be on the front lines of the abortion battle that how we convey our message and how the rest of the culture perceives our views is so important. The way we talk about abortion has made it sound just like every other Republican talking point, so that’s exactly how the broader culture views it.
Whatever the term “pro-life” originally meant, today it means something different than “abortion is murder.”Tweet ThisTwo major phenomena have led to the dilution of the term “pro-life,” one well-intentioned and one more sinister. The well-intentioned cause was that people who truly cared about saving babies determined that the primary way of doing this would be through winning elections, enacting policies, and changing hearts and minds in the political space. I have great respect for those who work to further these goals and save the lives of children. It is necessary to use politics to achieve our goals at times, and the evil of abortion does need to be addressed politically.
Unfortunately, a side effect of the politicization has been a watering down of the anti-abortion message. To win more votes, compromises have had to be made. Some of the strongest language about abortion had to be toned down. We’ve had to accept smaller victories at times. Legislators in Texas passed a “Heartbeat law” that banned abortion as soon as the child has a heartbeat. This law has almost certainly saved lives. Unfortunately, it has also probably led to a forgetfulness that many abortions happen before a heartbeat is detectable, and these are still babies being killed.
I am not calling into question the morality of these compromises. While I consider myself a complete abolitionist, I understand the arguments for the more gradual fight against abortion. What I would like to point out is the effect that this strategy has had on the idea of being “pro-life.”
Since being pro-life has meant working more gradually, Republican politicians have been able to get away with giving lip service to the pro-life cause, but doing little to support it once in office. Furthermore, the general politicization of the term has made it lose its edge in the culture as an extremely pressing problem. Again, this is a side effect of well-intentioned people (1) using politics to fight abortion, which is necessary and good, and (2) taking a step-by-step approach, which is a matter of prudence Catholics may disagree about. The important thing, rather than assigning blame, is to recognize the meaning-creep the term “pro-life” has undergone in the past 30 years because of this.
The important thing, rather than assigning blame, is to recognize the meaning-creep the term “pro-life” has undergone in the past 30 years because of this.Tweet ThisNow for the more sinister cause of the term’s dilution: feminism.
Feminism, an ideology that harms both sexes by treating the interests of men and women as separable and conflicting, has crept into the pro-life movement because of its general pervasiveness in our culture. The two options in polite society have been the radical feminism of the left, in which abortion is a sacrament, or the “first-wave” feminism of the right, in which the blame for abortion always seems to end up back on men. Many Catholics still seem to be under the impression that “first-wave” feminism, as opposed to radical feminism, is compatible with Christianity, and even that it was endorsed by Pope John Paul II. A thorough search into the origins of feminism, and into the actual writings of John Paul II in the context of his time, dispels these myths. Feminism has been rotten to the core from its inception, always focusing on the contempt of men and women’s quest to throw off the “yoke” of motherhood. John Paul II uses the word feminism only once in his magisterial writings; instead, he consistently speaks of women in terms of their womanhood and motherhood. For a more thorough debunking of these myths I would recommend Something Wicked by Dr. Carrie Gress.
One of the effects of feminism is that women are stripped of all agency when they do something wrong. This has been on full display in the past few months as feminists have defended murderers Lindsay Clancy and Christa Pike, as well as fraudster Elizabeth Holmes. In each case, the woman is not held accountable and is treated as if some outside force “made” them do horrible things; that outside force is generally a man or “the patriarchy.” The same thing has happened in the abortion discussion on the right. “One abortion, two victims.”
Somehow, the mother who murdered her tiny unborn child is now always a victim. Inevitably, the response to this will bring up two scenarios. First, the underage girl who is essentially forced by her parents to abort her child. In this case, I completely agree: the girl is a victim. However, cases in which the mother is under 18 make up around 2% of all abortions. We should be able to have a general discussion about abortion that doesn’t pretend 2% is any kind of majority.
The second scenario is that of a woman who has been lied to all her life and told that the unborn child is not alive yet or isn’t human. For this one, we aren’t giving ourselves enough credit. We anti-abortion people make noise. Everyone knows there are people out there who think every abortion is a murder. It comes up every election cycle. We may be looked at as crazy or fringe, but everyone knows we’re here.
Having an abortion without looking into the arguments of the anti-abortion side is like being on a hike and deciding to fire a bullet in a random direction without checking whether anyone was over there first. You might plead ignorance if you kill someone, but it would be willful ignorance. You would still be guilty of manslaughter. And if someone hiking with you had just hollered, “I think I see someone over there!” wouldn’t you be guilty of murder?
The “one abortion, two victims” slogan strips women of their agency. We simply don’t want to admit that the vast majority of women who obtain abortions knew they were ending the life of their child.
A 2024 analysis by the Charlotte Lozier Institute showed that 95.9% of abortions are elective and for reasons other than rape, incest, health concerns, or abnormalities in the baby. If we take away 2% of that for underage girls, we get about 94% of abortions being both elective and chosen by adult women because they just don’t want a kid. That means over a million babies are murdered in the womb by their mothers every year.
It may seem un-Christian to say these things about so many women. But no part of the Gospel, the Good News, downplays the bad news. Yes, you are a sinner. Repent and believe in the Gospel, and go and sin no more. The Gospel is not radical because it calls us to forgive ignorant people. It is radical because it calls us to forgive even murderers.
The Gospel is not radical because it calls us to forgive ignorant people. It is radical because it calls us to forgive even murderers.Tweet ThisNow you may be thinking, yes, all that is true, but we need to keep up the narrative in order to win votes. But as I outlined in my last article, Republican politicians use issues like the pro-life cause to gain votes, and promptly discard those issues when in office. Part of the reason for this is the watering down of what being pro-life means. If you believe abortion is murder, you have a serious, pressing duty to take concrete action. If you’re a pro-life feminist, all you need to do is give nice, empathetic platitudes on the campaign trail about how the difficult lot of women results in abortions that no one is culpable for but the abortionist and the boyfriend.
When a person is never disciplined, he will not develop the ability to manage strong emotions and curb his impulses. These people are less happy than those who, disciplined by their parents in their early years, or by life itself, are able to handle strong emotions and control their impulses. They’ve learned both the how and the why of right and wrong.
As a society, we treat modern women like children whom we do not wish to discipline. Instead of expecting them to live up to the standards of human dignity and morality, we justify every evil they commit as something that was not their fault, a just result of their emotions, or actually a man’s fault. As a result, they are less happy than if they were expected to understand that certain things are wrong, and that doing them is their own fault, regardless of what emotions might have been at play.
Unfortunately, this disease of unaccountability is spreading to men as well, especially on the left. Thankfully, the right has pushed back against the lack of agency when it comes to men. Young men are constantly being told that they must man up, take control of their lives, and be responsible for their actions. We have been too scared to do the same when it comes to women.
Abortion is murder, and a great holocaust. Remember that in the Gospels, as well as Revelation, there is much imagery of groups of people being judged together. We know that we will each receive a personal judgment, but as the people of this time, we will all be asked what we did during the great holocaust of unborn children. Practically, and as a matter of justice, we must call out women first and foremost for the abortion problem, and bravely assert that every abortion is murder.
There are no comments yet.