A series examining the newly released book by journalist and author Melanie McDonagh titled "Converts."
The key to unlocking the spirit and the theological perspective with which Mrs. McDonagh approaches the subject of converts to the Faith is to be found at the end of her chapter on “The Church in 1900.” Here she discusses the response to the modernist crisis in the Church by “a reactionary pope such as Pius X.” The reaction to modernism was “disastrous,” she writes; “it was to stifle intellectual debate, to curb genuine biblical scholarship and impose an arid neo-Thomist – that of St Thomas Aquinas – scholasticism on seminaries.”
Let’s provide a little historical context.
The Thomistic revival did not begin with St. Pius X but with his predecessor, Leo XIII, who sought to reassert the primacy of the theological teaching of St. Thomas Aquinas. Far from being a “reactionary,” Leo was one of the most dynamic engagers with the culture, calling for its radical reform. In his encyclical, Rerum Novarum, promulgated in 1891, he explicated the Church’s social teaching in the light of “new things,” exposing the errors of both communism and socialism, on the one hand, and laissez-faire capitalism, on the other. Insisting on the right to the ownership of private property as the only sure foundation of political and economic freedom, Pope Leo’s encyclical also insisted upon the principles later called subsidiarity and solidarity as the two pillars of a just social order. Subsidiarity placed and rooted political and economic order in the sacrosanct rights of the family, upon which economic liberty, social cohesion, and the common good (solidarity) are ultimately dependent.
Such was the wisdom and the impact of Leo XIII’s encyclical that it inspired future popes to base their own explication of the Church’s social teaching upon its groundbreaking principles. Pius XI promulgated the social encyclical, Quadragesimo Anno, in 1931 to commemorate and celebrate the fortieth anniversary of Rerum Novarum, reiterating its principles in the wake of the rise of Bolshevism in Russia and fascism in Italy. Following this noble tradition, St. John Paul II would issue his own encyclical, Centesimus Annus, on the centenary of the promulgation of Rerum Novarum in 1991.
Needless to say, the social teaching of Rerum Novarum is rooted in Scripture and magisterial doctrine, especially the theology and philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas, the teaching of whom Mrs. McDonagh seems to dismiss as “arid” and “reactionary.” In point of fact, the social teaching of the Church would attract numerous converts to the Faith, especially between the two world wars, because the Church’s teaching was seen as the only sane and sensible alternative to capitalism and socialism, and to the totalitarianism of fascism, National Socialism, and communism. In England, Hilaire Belloc and G. K. Chesterton championed the Church’s social teaching. Belloc wrote The Servile State (1912) and An Essay on the Restoration of Property (1936), whereas Chesterton wrote What’s Wrong with the World (1910) and The Outline of Sanity (1926). These works are an important part of the Catholic revival in England of which Mrs. McDonagh writes, each of which is based on a Thomistic understanding of political philosophy, and each of which is truly dynamic and radical in its approach to economic and ideological errors.
Far from being a “reactionary,” Leo was one of the most dynamic engagers with the culture, calling for its radical reform.Tweet ThisHaving traced the birth of the anything but “arid” Thomistic revival to the papacy of his predecessor, let’s return to St. Pius X, whom Mrs. McDonagh dismisses for being “a reactionary pope.”
Apart from continuing the promotion of the Thomistic revival, St. Pius called for the active participation of the faithful in the liturgy (participatio actuosa) in his motu proprio, Tra le sollecitudini (1903). He encouraged the frequent reception of Holy Communion and lowered the age for First Communion, two great and enduring reforms of his papacy that have greatly enriched the practice of the Faith.
Born into poverty, St. Pius X retained a poverty of spirit throughout his life. As a Third Order Franciscan, he lived an austere and ascetic life, combining the faithful simplicity of St. Francis with the philosophical brilliance of St. Thomas Aquinas, thereby uniting both the Franciscan and Dominican charisms. In this union of faith and reason, or sanctity and sanity, we might be reminded once again of G. K. Chesterton, who wrote two great books on the lives of two great saints, St. Francis of Assisi (1923) and St. Thomas Aquinas (1933).
Such was Pius X’s reputation for holiness that several authenticated miraculous healings were ascribed to him during his pontificate. In 1944, thirty years after his death, his body was exhumed as part of the beatification process and was found to be miraculously incorrupt. He was canonized ten years later by Pope Pius XII.
As a Third Order Franciscan, he lived an austere and ascetic life, combining the faithful simplicity of St. Francis with the philosophical brilliance of St. Thomas Aquinas, thereby uniting both the Franciscan and Dominican charisms.Tweet ThisIt beggars belief that this wonderful and holy saint of the Church should be dismissed as “a reactionary pope” purely because he stood faithfully and fearlessly against the heresy of modernism, which sought to bring the Church into conformity with the spirit of the progressivist age. Thus, for instance, Mrs. McDonagh seems surprised that Lord Alfred Douglas, “with his unerring instinct to swim against the tide, was drawn into the Church precisely by one of Pius X’s anti-modernist encyclicals.” It seems that the “modern” Church needed to swim with the tide, to go with the flow of the times. Perhaps Mrs. McDonagh should be reminded of Chesterton’s aphoristic wisdom, which reminds us that only a corpse flows with the stream; it takes someone fully alive to swim against it. Similarly, to paraphrase another of Chesterton’s aphorisms, only a corpse does not react; a living person or, for that matter, a living faith, reacts healthily to unhealthy attacks upon it. To be reactionary, in the good sense, is to respond healthily to unhealthy attacks.
All such logic or wisdom appears lost on Mrs. McDonagh, who opines at the end of her chapter on “The Church in 1900” that “[i]t was a repressive Church on the defensive that converts joined at the beginning of the century.” “Nonetheless,” she continues, “intellectuals, writers and artists were to migrate to the Catholic Church in significant numbers in the decades that followed, as did many ordinary men and women.” It doesn’t seem to dawn on Mrs. McDonagh that they were joining the Church because She was reactionary, in the good sense. They were joining the Church because She was defensive enough to defend the unchanging truths of the Gospel against modernist misinterpretations of Scripture and doctrine. To borrow another aphorism attributed to Chesterton, they were joining because they didn’t want a church that would move with the world but a church that would move the world. Saints move the world; heretics are moved by it. Thanks to holy heroes and healthy reactionaries, such as Pius X, the saints prevailed.
There are no comments yet.