Losing Our Legacy

As America turns 250, the generations who witnessed her goodness are passing, and we are losing our glorious, unifying legacy. Franklin gave us “a republic, if you can keep it.” To do so, we must safeguard our legacy.

PUBLISHED ON

November 18, 2026

With devastating consequences, we are losing our glorious, unifying American legacy.

God blessed America with incredibly intelligent, wise, and, yes, despite revisionist history, moral Founding Fathers. Under divine providence, they succeeded against seemingly insurmountable challenges. Never before or since has such a small group of men structured a new country with such insightful perspective and uncanny foresight.

The Founders rejected the political belief of the age that a monarch derives a right to rule directly from God rather than from the consent of the people. They were very aware of the limitations and flaws of man. So, they put in place a constitutional republic, with three separate but equal branches of government, a system of checks and balances, and a governing document that is political genius. The accompanying Bill of Rights recognized and guaranteed God-given freedoms and liberties. The Founders were adamant that rights do not come from government; government exists primarily to secure them.

The foundation of the new United States was built on very clear Christian concepts. The Founding Fathers in their documents and letters make numerous mentions of God and His role in the governing of America.

James Madison, widely regarded as the chief architect of the U.S. Constitution, is attributed with saying, “The future and success of America is not in this Constitution, but in the laws of God upon which this Constitution is founded.” John Adams stated that “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious People. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.” George Washington, in his Farewell Address, cautioned that national morality could not be sustained apart from religious principle.

With the help of France, our early American citizen-soldiers defeated the mightiest empire of the day. Heading west, brave American explorers such as Daniel Boone, Lewis and Clark, John Colter, and God-fearing Jedediah Smith blazed trails throughout the wilderness. The pioneers soon followed.

Our country was young, energetic, expanding, and filled with opportunities. In the 1830s, visiting French observer Alexis de Tocqueville noted that Americans constantly formed independent civic, moral, and commercial groups to solve community problems instead of relying on the government. Rugged individualism was also part of the developing American character, as was the strong influence and peaceful ascendancy of religion in America.

During the Civil War, President Abraham Lincoln, under incredible pressures, preserved the Union. At the cost of over 1 million Americans (killed, wounded, captured, and missing) out of a total population of approximately 31 million, the great American experiment was saved and the scourge of slavery ended.

Lincoln frequently invoked and quoted the Founding Fathers throughout his public speeches, debates, and writing, as well as regularly mentioning God and Divine Providence.

In his magnificent Gettysburg Address, Lincoln recalled our legacy: “Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal . . . this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom—and that government of the people, by the people, for the people shall not perish from the earth.”

The Civil War birthed new American heroes—on both sides of the conflict. Gettysburg, Antietam, Shiloh, Chancellorsville, and so many other fields of valor are consecrated with the blood of those who sacrificed all.

The end of the 19th century witnessed American inventions such as the telephone and the incandescent light bulb. American entrepreneurship and inventiveness were the driving forces of industrialization, manufacturing, and new product development.

The American spirit carried over into the 20th century. In 1903, the Wright brothers made their first powered flight. Sixty-six years later, American astronauts landed on the moon. Henry Ford popularized mass production using the moving assembly line, transforming personal travel and the automotive industry. The engineering marvel of the early 20th century was building the Panama Canal, which could only succeed after Americans tamed malaria. In 1955, Jonas Salk’s polio vaccine was declared safe and effective against polio.

The U.S. entry into World War I ensured victory for the Allied Powers. The American military, our industrial and manufacturing might, a united people, and solid leadership were the essential keys in defeating Nazi Germany. The U.S. introduction of the nuclear age ended the war against Imperial Japan. American generosity and the Marshall Plan rebuilt devastated Europe and our defeated enemies.

With a big moral and spiritual assist from Pope John Paul II, American treasure, industrial might, and military armaments and readiness defeated the Soviet Union.

Countless American inventions including the transistor, television, mobile phone, microprocessor, internet, digital technology, biotechnology, energy, advanced manufacturing, medical breakthroughs, space age communications, and modern agricultural production are just a few of the ways the world has benefited from American creativeness.

The Founders were adamant that rights do not come from government; government exists primarily to secure them.Tweet This

In 2026, our country is celebrating its 250th birthday. Yet there are shorter markers of connectivity. About every 70-80 years, direct eyewitnesses to historical events grow old and pass away, moving events from living memory into recorded history. Our legacy has been passed forward by witnesses.

In 1838, a young Abraham Lincoln delivered a speech that underscored that common memory helped sustain our institutions and our freedoms in the perilous infancy of the nation. Americans were a united people. They remembered why they fought in the Revolution and the sacrifices that were made. Memory was fresh because of “living history”; many of the patriots who did the fighting were still to be found in the family and public square.

My father, who was born in 1917, told me he could recall soldiers of the Civil War walking in civic parades. Dad fought in World War II and Korea. He passed away years later as a result of witnessing atomic testing in the Nevada desert during the Cold War.

I was impacted by the quiet valor of veterans as well as the humble heroes of the American home front. Americans made sacrifices. We were not dependent on government largesse. We celebrated our common legacy and lived e pluribus unum. There were no hyphens. We were all Americans—and proud of it.

Incredibly, that was only the third 70-year link back to the Founding Fathers. Today, we are about 70 years removed from the 1950s golden age of America. That generation, a witness to America’s goodness, is passing. Moderns are losing our legacy.

We celebrated our common legacy and lived e pluribus unum. There were no hyphens. We were all Americans—and proud of it.Tweet This

When I was in elementary school, I read every biography and history book in our school library. The books were a celebration of America. They extolled patriotism, responsibility, virtues, and the ideals on which our country was founded.

Go into a library or bookstore today. There are few books about traditional American heroes or ones that extol our magnificent legacy. In contrast, there is plenty of material on antiheroes, Hollywood celebrities, sports stars, celebrations of DEI, and just plain weird, mindless, vapid pap. Books for young people seem trivialized, dumbed down, and are often presented in graphic novel (comic book) format.

With few exceptions, inspiring American history is not taught in schools and universities today. Statues of great Americans including Washington, Lincoln, and Jefferson are toppled and defaced. In the past, Columbus Day parades were common in American towns. Today, Columbus is portrayed by revisionists as a mass murderer of indigenous peoples. The Smithsonian Institution promotes anti-American exhibits, rewriting our nation’s history—in President Trump’s words, “replacing objective facts with a distorted narrative driven by ideology.” Battlefields and national landmarks have exhibits promoting interpretations of the dark side of American history.

I am not discounting the blemishes of America’s legacy. Slavery, the subjugation of Native Americans, civil rights abuses, and inequalities are also part of our history. Humankind has a fallen nature and is prone to sin. But our country has spent blood and treasure to help rectify mistakes of the past. We have made tremendous progress. I challenge anyone to name any other country that has done more.

With the constant drumbeat of negativity, it is not a surprise that a 2026 Gallup poll showed that American pride has fallen to a 25-year low. Only 14% of Democrats say they are extremely proud to be American. Forty-two percent of American college students would rather live in a socialist system as opposed to 28% who prefer to live in a capitalist one. More than one in five students believe America deserved September 11. This correlates with other polling that shows Americans are in a steep religious freefall.

The 70-year “living history” of our legacy is not working for moderns. The personal link to the past seems broken. Critics use today’s shallow values and prism to judge others. Their revisionist views are cancerous. The generations before us faced challenges and had an outlook on life that critics know nothing about. Moderns cannot see their own faults. In Matthew 7:3-5, Jesus addresses hypocrisy and the human tendency to harshly judge or nitpick faults in others while ignoring major sins or flaws in ourselves. I can only imagine what later generations will have to say about what is going on today.

But our country has spent blood and treasure to help rectify mistakes of the past. We have made tremendous progress.Tweet This

There are three major reasons for the lessening of our legacy.

About 100 years ago, socialists/communists initiated the “long march through the institutions.” It’s a political and cultural strategy based partially on the writings of Italian Marxist Antonio Gramsci. The strategy aims to slowly infiltrate and subvert cultural, educational, media, unions, associations, and religious institutions from within. Marxists in America have been quietly reshaping societal norms and values over generations, with assistance from the former Soviet Union and now the Chinese Communist Party. They systematically reframe and rewrite our historical legacy through the lens of Marxist ideology.

Another major reason is our changing immigration patterns. The Hart-Celler Act of 1965, floor-managed by Sen. Ted Kennedy, fundamentally reshaped U.S. immigration law. Previously, the great majority of immigrants to the United States had shared Western values and Christian faith. They learned English, assimilated, and proudly adopted the American legacy. Today’s immigrants, both legal and illegal, often come from cultures that reject traditional American values, our heritage, and reject the obligations of American citizenship.

Over the last decades, we constantly heard that “diversity is our strength.” In fact, our strength was (past tense intended) unity. Social cohesion is not self-sustaining. To be “one nation under God, indivisible” requires a core shared accepted legacy.

The recent election could accelerate our demise. Democratic socialists’ plan is to hasten the tearing down and destruction of our American legacy. Their agenda calls for abolishing the Electoral College, replacing the U.S. presidency with an executive system chosen directly by Congress, abolishing the U.S. Senate, expanding the House of Representatives, implementing ranked-choice voting, and replacing or restructuring the Supreme Court.

Do these moral and intellectual midgets think they know better than our Founding Fathers?

The third cause of decline is that our country may historically be reaching the end of its rising and prosperous epochs. Sir John Bagot Glubb outlined a predictable lifecycle for great empires. He postulated that most great civilizations last roughly 250 years before collapsing from internal decay. Honest observers will acknowledge that the United States has entered Glubb’s final phases of collapse: an age marked by decadence, internal rot, materialism, frivolity, high debt, dependency, a welfare state, and a weakening of religion and moral decay. Glubb concludes that the internally weakened empire becomes fragile and vulnerable to diverse external or internal shocks.

On Sept. 18, 1787, the day after the U.S. Constitution was signed inside Independence Hall, Benjamin Franklin was asked what kind of government was created. He replied, “A republic, if you can keep it.”

To do so, we must safeguard our legacy.

Our Lady of America, pray for us.

Author

Orthodox. Faithful. Free.

Sign up to get Crisis articles delivered to your inbox daily

Email subscribe inline (#4)

Join the Conversation

Comments are a benefit for financial supporters of Crisis. If you are a monthly or annual supporter, please login to comment. A Crisis account has been created for you using the email address you used to donate.

Donate

There are no comments yet.

Editor's picks

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00
Share to...