What If Our Hatred Is Just?

Forgiveness is indispensable to the Christian life, but we cannot downplay its cost. To will that those who have hurt us might join us in Heaven is to love God more than we value our own hatred and resentment.

PUBLISHED ON

November 18, 2026

When President Trump was interviewed by Ross Douthat for 60 Minutes in the aftermath of the midterm elections, he shared a wounded part of his soul with the world. In reacting too quickly, we make the same error over which he stumbled in front of the camera, reducing the Christian calling to a view of justice that none of us can rise to.

Let us recap the part of the conversation that has drawn so much ire:

Ross Douthat: Mr. President, you have had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you are telling me that before the judgment throne of God you couldn’t find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that’s been given to you? Come on. Help me out here.

President Donald Trump: I mean, it’s such an easy answer. All I have to do is say, “Yes, I can.”

Ross Douthat: I– I, again, I don’t think it’s an easy answer–

President Donald Trump: Honestly, Ross, can I– can I be honest–

Ross Douthat: –that’s why I asked it. Yes.

President Donald Trump: I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will.

In context, President Trump means that it would be easy to say what the interviewer wants to hear, but it would be a lie. Earlier in the conversation, he connects the misdeeds of his enemies with their deservedness of forgiveness. We need not (and ought not) do that.

In the ensuing fallout, online pundits have debated whether or not President Trump’s hatred is justified, and whether forgiveness therefore might constitute an injustice that he should not even aspire to. Others repeated Ross Douthat’s incredulity at Trump’s rage, given his life of wealth and above-average social status.

In context, President Trump means that it would be easy to say what the interviewer wants to hear, but it would be a lie.Tweet This

A fuller accounting can grant clarity. For example, his political enemies did not just win races against him and say disparaging things; they weaponized the judicial system against him and his family members. Before his 2024 election, it seemed very likely that he or one of his children was going to serve prison time as a result of an unjust and pernicious prosecution. Some of his political allies did suffer that fate as a result of their relationship to him. These are not trivial details, and it’s unfair for them to be disregarded beneath a narrative that Trump has merely lived a “charmed life.”

We should always be cautious about summarizing the life and suffering of another, and how their crosses have weighed on them. Let us not judge like communists who associate wealth with mere oppression and who use that miscategorization to dehumanize those whom their envy would rather see eliminated. Suffering is not distributed evenly, but rare would be the man who has been untouched. We all live around flawed people, and we have to cope with the mixed-hearted villain in the mirror. We cannot know the tally of another man’s burdens, and no anthology of biographies can tell us of the brokenness they caused.

We can at least know that he was so pained by his older brother Fred’s struggle with alcoholism that he avoided alcohol and cigarettes throughout his life. Since then, he’s lost Fred, his mother and father, his older sister Maryanne, his younger brother Robert, and his first wife. We know that by virtue of his family lineage, his version of failure would look like success to most of us. Those are expectations that many would find crippling, and he fell short of corporate success publicly on more than one occasion. Failing to recognize the humanity of a celebrity distorts our vision and numbs us to a rightful compassion.

Failing to recognize the humanity of a celebrity distorts our vision and numbs us to a rightful compassion.Tweet This

If we are to hold forgiveness as an indispensable component of a Christian life—and we do because Christ did—then we cannot do the injustice of downplaying the cost. By reducing the gravity of the act of forgiveness, we flatten the goodness of that choice. We engage in a mere trite Christianity, which Dietrich Bonhoeffer called “cheap grace,” in which we pretend and proclaim that the Faith is costless.

Let us look more accurately on the caliber of men who could honestly say “Yes” to the question. When St. Edmund Campion wrote to Queen Elizabeth I’s Privy Council of his and his fellow missionaries’ task, he was already aware of the abject evils she had mandated. She had already been responsible for the deaths of his friends. She made no apology and had no plans to relent. And yet it was in that environment that he wrote:

“Many innocent hands are lifted up to heaven for you daily by those English students, whose posterity shall never die, which beyond seas, gathering virtue and sufficient knowledge for the purpose, are determined never to give you over, but either to win you heaven, or to die upon your pikes.”

She would ultimately kill him too, but he died fighting “to win you heaven” and, in so doing, won his own place there. That kind of forgiveness—the type that yearns for the good of the person’s destiny in spite of their evils—is so contrary to our nature that it could be said to be in some sense inhuman. It is what St. Maximus the Confessor meant when he asserted that we are to become as Divine by grace as Christ is by nature.

That kind of forgiveness—the type that yearns for the good of the person’s destiny in spite of their evils—is so contrary to our nature that it could be said to be in some sense inhuman.Tweet This

To will that those who have hurt us might join us in Heaven is to love God more than we value our own hatred and resentment. After all, we can know that He wants all people to be united with Him, for they only exist at all as a result of His hand. To hate them is to desire their worst end, which is the deprivation of God in the hereafter, which we should grieve if only because of the injury done to Him who loved them (and us) perfectly.

Our forgiveness of the evils of others cannot depend on their worthiness, lest we too be damned by our own inability to atone for those acts we have committed against an infinite God, as well as our fellow man.

We still have enough of a Christian culture left that we rightly recoil when we hear someone describe their hatred or their refusal to even attempt forgiveness. In so doing, we give a nod to the moral giants who came before us, who understood the cost, bore it willingly, and reached a Home at whose doors they could lay down their crosses, and hear the words, “Well done, good and faithful servant.” Those are the leaders whom we must exalt, not because it was ever easy, but because they were willing to die rather than surrender the only fight that matters.

Author

  • Sarah Cain, known as The Crusader Gal, is a political and cultural commentator who makes videos about the decline of the West, and she writes Homefront Crusade. She is the author of Failing Foundations: The Pillars of the West Are Nearing Collapse.

Orthodox. Faithful. Free.

Sign up to get Crisis articles delivered to your inbox daily

Email subscribe inline (#4)

Join the Conversation

Comments are a benefit for financial supporters of Crisis. If you are a monthly or annual supporter, please login to comment. A Crisis account has been created for you using the email address you used to donate.

Donate

There are no comments yet.

Editor's picks

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00
Share to...