Christ-Centered Catholic Spirituality: From Quietism to Spiritual Bankruptcy

After Quietism, contemplation was systematically taken out of religious life and therefore out of family life, leaving the Church heading toward the spiritual bankruptcy in which we find ourselves today.

PUBLISHED ON

November 16, 2026

In many ways, the history that I have been trying to develop in summary form has been the history of contemplation, without which we are nothing, and we will achieve nothing of any serious consequence for the good of God’s Kingdom on earth. In whichever way prayer begins, those who choose to go deeper will always be led into meditation and then through meditation, into contemplation. In other words, into meditation on the life of Christ as He was in the past, so that we are filled with the desire to be united with Him in the present. If we persevere then God leads us into contemplation to be united with Christ as He is now, and into His contemplative loving of the Father.

The darkness and the aridity and the many distractions and temptations that surround us when we are first led into contemplation make us think we are on the wrong way. But we are not. These are the signs given by the great mystics to convince a person that we are on the right way and in the right place. By the right place I mean the place where we must learn to give selflessly to God as we continually try to raise our heart and mind to Him as best we can, although we seem to receive nothing in return. The self-sacrifice that is learned here enables a person’s love to be so purified that it can be progressively made one with the love of Jesus Christ, in whom, and with whom our love will be raised to God the Father. Here we contemplate His glory and receive in return what Saint Thomas Aquinas calls the fruits of contemplation, namely all the infused virtues, without which we are nothing.

If you think this is only for “pious souls” then stop and think for a moment because you and many millions of other Catholics have been deceived by the power of evil. Union with God, for which God created us from the beginning, can only take place after the sins and the selfishness that have eroded, corroded, and corrupted us from the inside have been progressively and permanently removed by the fire of the Holy Spirit. This purification takes place in contemplative prayer where we are continually asked to keep giving although we receive or seem to receive nothing in return.

This purification has been long since forgotten by the present generation of Catholics, from top to bottom, thanks to the aftermath of the heresy of Quietism. It was only after Quietism that theocentric, God-centered spirituality that centers its attention on loving God Himself began to wane, and anthropocentric or man-centered spirituality began to take the lead. This has happened not just in the new activity-centered congregations, but in the older orders too who, without contemplation as their very raison d’être, began to lose their way.

Before Arianism in the early Church, the family was the place where, through meditating on Christ, contemplation was first born in ordinary lay people, in whom Christianity was seen to be perfectly embodied. Nor does it take years for a person to be led by God into contemplation, if they only demonstrate to God by their perseverance in meditation that they do genuinely want to be united with Him. After Arianism, as we have seen, it was to religious life that people would look in the future to see the perfection of the Christian life being lived in profound contemplation, while the faithful were in general left languishing. However, after Quietism, when contemplation was systematically taken out of religious life and therefore out of family life, then the Church was spiritually bereft, and heading toward the spiritual bankruptcy in which we find ourselves today. Nor is the solution to find the most perfect liturgy, as many seem to believe. For the liturgy is the outward expression of the inner mystical life that has long since been forgotten.

Nor is the solution to find the most perfect liturgy, as many seem to believe. For the liturgy is the outward expression of the inner mystical life that has long since been forgotten.Tweet This

It was, of course, a slow process in those days without the mass media that we have today, but after two centuries or so, the contemplation upon which Catholic spirituality was founded was already disappearing. But there were still many mystics, as can be seen in books like The Graces of Interior Prayer by Fr. Augustin Poulain, SJ, who, while remaining a non-practitioner himself, made a remarkable and accurate study of contemplative prayer, as it existed toward the end of the 19th century in certain communities and in certain religious people, most particularly in France. The book received the approbation of Pope Pius X at a time of rising interest in pseudo-mysticism like Theosophy and in secular mysticism generally, encouraged by William James in his book Varieties of Religious Experience.

However, mysticism in general was viewed as yet another form of the modernism that was condemned in Pope Pius X’s encyclical in 1907, Pascendi Dominici Gregis—On the Doctrines of the Modernists. It was the new Catholic antipathy toward mystical theology that prevented Evelyn Underhill, the great Anglo-Catholic mystical writer, from becoming a Catholic. Although Abbot Butler’s scholarly work on Western Mysticism published in 1922 is a classic, the author makes it clear that he himself was not a practitioner, nor does he encourage it. He writes in his epilogue: “I have never had any mystical experiences myself, never had anything that could be called an experiential perception of God or His presence.”

When, however, Pope Pius XI named Saint John of the Cross as a Doctor of the Church in 1926, referring to him as a “Mystical Doctor,” a new interest in mystical contemplation arose for a time, as different religious orders tried to show how their spirituality was in fact in conformity with his. However, the long spiritual dark night of the soul that had persisted in Catholic spirituality in the aftermath of Quietism meant there was nobody available who was competent enough to lead.

In the 1930s, there were a few voices crying in the wilderness, like that of Dom John Chapman, who became famous for his retreats that called people back to contemplative prayer, but few were really listening. The publication of The Three Ages of the Interior Life by Fr. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, on the eve of the Second World War, was contemplative prayer’s last stand. This masterwork is perhaps the most revered, and yet the least read of modern spiritual classics. The Thomistic renewal that took place in the Church in the 1950s was a return to a renewal primarily of the head, not of the heart. As Friedrich Nietzsche would put it, “mystical theology was dead,” long before I entered religious life in 1957 to find out for myself. Modern Thomists seemed to be totally ignorant of the fact that Saint Thomas Aquinas’s Summa was written by a man formed and inspired by contemplative prayer. Nor, therefore, will it be deeply understood by modern scholastic scholars who have never been formed or inspired by the same contemplative prayer that inspired St. Thomas.

The Thomistic renewal that took place in the Church in the 1950s was a return to a renewal primarily of the head, not of the heart.Tweet This

The evil in the Church that seemed to flourish immediately after the Second Vatican Council was already in place before the Council began, but it was restrained by a strict authoritarianism that progressively evaporated during and after “the swinging ’60s.” I know this because I was there. I was born before the Second World War and received my “spiritual education” in the 1940s and 1950s before I was ordained in 1964. I also therefore know that postwar Catholic faith and practice was not the golden age to which many fantasists believe we should all return.

Thanks to the revelations of Our Lady of Fatima, there was, however, one last hope. She had instructed the Holy Father to call the whole Church to follow, with renewed vigor, her Divine Son’s original spiritual teaching to Repent, to Pray, and to Sacrifice in 1960. Pope John XXIII had already called for a Council instead, to do with human wisdom what could and can only be done by Divine Wisdom.

Has there ever been such a council before, when those who had come to deliberate on how to adapt the Church to the modern world and how to work together for Christian unity, had long since been denied, not just contemplative prayer, but what Saint Thomas Aquinas called the fruits of contemplation? Without true infused wisdom, prudence, fortitude, and the other infused Cardinal and Moral Virtues, how could they ever hope to succeed with secular wisdom alone? It is one thing to invoke the help of the Holy Spirit in prayer when they assembled in Rome, but if those who made that prayer had been for years deprived of the profound contemplation that had inspired previous conciliar Fathers, how could the Second Vatican Council hope to succeed as previous councils had done before them?

I also therefore know that postwar Catholic faith and practice was not the golden age to which many fantasists believe we should all return.Tweet This

In my final retreat before joining the Franciscan order, the Jesuit retreat master told us that he had recently received Douglas Hyde, the former news editor of the British Communist Daily Worker, into the Church. Instead of using the opportunity to condemn communism, the retreat master said that it had many praiseworthy characteristics that we should emulate, and, had the headmaster not intervened, he would have set up “Catholic Communist Cells” in our school to bring about a new all-embracing world order. Fast forward to 1965 when, according to the book The Jesuits by the former Jesuit Malachi Martin, the congregation were, on the death of their general, called to a council in Rome. According to Fr. Martin, two-thirds of the General Assembly were committed to rebuilding the Jesuit order, and then the Church, according to the Marxist principles found in liberation theology. The new general, Father Arrupe, had led one of the first rescue teams into Hiroshima after the atom bomb fell at the end of the Second World War. He had seen what capitalism had done, and so he was eager to introduce into the Jesuit congregation and through them into the Church, thence into the world, a new world order that would prevent such things ever happening again.

As I saw and experienced for myself in the 1970s and 1980s, the traditional Jesuit spirituality was superseded by a new type of spirituality, albeit a man-made spirituality, that would bring to birth in religious communities, the embryonic beginnings of the New World Order to which they aspired. It was a socio-psychological spirituality.

Under the pretext of helping bereft religious communities to rediscover their charisms, Jesuit apostles came to introduce their own form of socio-psychological “spirituality” that turned communities into therapeutic self-help welfare groups. Anything and everything could be said; everybody was encouraged to speak their mind about themselves, about their needs, about the needs of the world and about the needs of the future Church. All ideas, however outlandish, could be voiced and must be listened to without criticism, for in the new world order all ideas would be accepted with sympathy and with understanding. Nothing would be off the agenda except returning to the “rigidity” of the old ecclesiastical order from which they had escaped.

Thanks to the Jesuits and their anthropocentric spirituality, along with many others, the way to what today is called Synodality was introduced by the Jesuit Pope Francis into the Church as a new way of government. It should also be replicated at ground level in our parishes and in our religious communities where the idea of synodality had already been tried and failed as hundreds of communities were destroyed along with countless individuals, psychologically broken by amateur psychologists posing as heralds of the New World Order.

Remember, anything goes except going back to the traditional Catholic spirituality that I have been trying to outline. As every Catholic with the “sensus fidelium” should now be able to see, those who should know better are at present systematically dismantling the God-given spirituality that was lived by Jesus Christ our Lord before He bequeathed it to the early Church.

Under the pretext of helping bereft religious communities to rediscover their charisms, Jesuit apostles came to introduce their own form of socio-psychological “spirituality.”Tweet This

Our only hope is to do what was done in the early days of the Church, and that is to look to Our Lady, the Mother of the Church, to see her as the perfect exemplification of what must be done if the Church is to be renewed before total disaster finally takes place. In order to practice the teaching of Our Lady, that was originally responsible for the swift rise of the early Church, and the conquest of a pagan Roman Empire, the teaching of Saint Angela of Foligno must be followed to the letter. We must go back, she said, and without delay, to what she called the Schola Divini Amoris. Here the message that Our Lady wanted to be proclaimed to the Universal Church in 1960 would now have a school into which the faithful could return in order to practice sacrifice, repentance, and prayer.

The first sacrifices that would have to be made in order to go back to this school would be to give all and everything else up that would prevent you going back to the “School of Divine Love”, which of course is personal prayer. In this school, true selfless loving will be learned, that would enable you to keep turning back to God again and again through repenting, most particularly in prayer. Prayer is the place where you learn divine loving by repeatedly trying to make acts of love in darkness, aridity, dryness, and amid distractions and temptations. It is here where you freely choose to turn your will back to God again and again and again, to enable the love of God, the Holy Spirit, to enter into you and to transform you from within.

When we practice Our Lady’s call back to Repentance, Prayer, and Sacrifice, we take the sacrifices that we have made in order to go, and to go daily, into the School of Divine Love, together with the sacrifices that we make in continually trying to raise our heart and minds to God inside of prayer, at the Sacrifice of the Mass. It is here that we are united with the sacrifice of Christ our High Priest. Then, in Holy Communion, and to the measure in which we have given, God gives us His love without measure, to continue in the forthcoming weeks, months, and years, to keep up the practice of dying to self and rising to receive the Holy Spirit in the School of Divine Love.

Then, when at the beginning of each day, and in imitation of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, we offer the forthcoming day to God our Father, in, with, and through Jesus Christ, we can continue to receive the daily spiritual food and drink that we need to sustain us. This is the food for which we have already prayed in the Lord’s Prayer when we say “Give us this day Our Daily Bread.” For those who do not know how to begin to pray in the Schola Divini Amoris, please go to https://metanoia.org.uk, where you will find the help you need.

Author

  • David Torkington is a Spiritual Theologian, Author and Speaker who specializes in Prayer, Christian Spirituality and Mystical Theology. You can find out more about him at davidtorkington.com.

Orthodox. Faithful. Free.

Sign up to get Crisis articles delivered to your inbox daily

Email subscribe inline (#4)

Join the Conversation

Comments are a benefit for financial supporters of Crisis. If you are a monthly or annual supporter, please login to comment. A Crisis account has been created for you using the email address you used to donate.

Donate

There are no comments yet.

Editor's picks

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00
Share to...