It’s Child P*rn, Not CSAM!

Even conservatives have quickly adopted the term “CSAM” in place of “child porn.” But the new phrase is vague, clinical, and absent from U.S. law—and it may open the door to AI-generated child porn.

PUBLISHED ON

November 20, 2026

Notice that we used an asterisk in the word “porn” in the headline. This is because using the full, undisguised word would cause some email systems to block this column. Why would that be? Because porn is evil and pretty much everyone knows what it means, including the algorithm.

Now consider the other word up there—CSAM. Quick, without looking: do you know what CSAM is, what it refers to, or even what the letters mean? Some might, most won’t. And even among those who might know what it refers to, hardly any will know where it comes from or why it was introduced. And yet so many of us have come to use it so quickly.

CSAM is “child sexual abuse material.” It is the word the cognoscenti, including our friends on the right, including the Christian right, have adopted instead of that crystalline phrase “child porn.” Notice immediately how vague it is. What does “material” refer to? On its face, it is not as clear as porn.

Did you know they are not the same thing? Not many do. Instead, we dutifully fall in line with the new language. Consider how easily we on the right lose the language battles.

Consider how easily we on the right lose the language battles.Tweet This

First, there is no definition of CSAM in U.S. federal law. In U.S. law, we still use the definition of child porn:

“child pornography” means any visual depiction, including any photograph, film, video, picture, or computer or computer-generated image or picture, whether made or produced by electronic, mechanical, or other means, of sexually explicit conduct, where— (A) the production of such visual depiction involves the use of a minor engaging in sexually explicit conduct; (B) such visual depiction is a digital image, computer image, or computer-generated image that is, or is indistinguishable from, that of a minor engaging in sexually explicit conduct; or (C) such visual depiction has been created, adapted, or modified to appear that an identifiable minor is engaging in sexually explicit conduct.

The law gets graphically specific, which would curl your hair in contemplating what perverts do with children.

Advocates of the term CSAM would include all of this with one exception that I will get to in a minute. In the meantime, I want to make clear that the definition of CSAM used by advocacy groups does include a wider definition of “material” than hard U.S. law does, such as “child erotica,” that is, children posed in provocative ways but without nudity. But the problem comes with the exception allowed by the newish U.N. treaty on cybercrimes, which has yet to come into force but is headed in that direction.

The new cybercrime treaty lets countries exempt sexualized material involving children that does not depict an actual person, thus opening the door to AI-generated child porn. Countries may make that illegal, but the treaty does not require it.

The new cybercrime treaty lets countries exempt sexualized material involving children that does not depict an actual person, thus opening the door to AI-generated child porn.Tweet This

CSAM comes from something called the harm-reduction approach. As my colleague Stefano Gennarini reported last year, “According to proponents of this approach, merely stigmatizing pedophilia and ostracizing those who sexualize children for their own pleasure will lead to more illegal sexual abuse. They would rather legitimize pedophilia as a sexual orientation (using the term ‘minor-attracted persons’ to reduce stigma) and let pedophiles continue to sexualize children virtually. They assume that doing this will limit the harms to real children.”

As Gennarini reported, “the most widely cited source for replacing the term ‘child pornography’ with CSAM” is a document called the Luxembourg Guidelines, and something called “trauma-informed analysis.” The trauma-informed approach “requires health professionals to be careful about the language and gestures they use to avoid ‘re-victimizing’ their patients by recalling a traumatic event.” It’s argued that “because pornography is a consensual activity between adults, using the term ‘child pornography’ implies willing participation by the abused child. This stigmatizes or victimizes any child who is depicted in child pornography.”

The bottom-line problems with CSAM are that it does not match federal law, even though the term is increasingly popular (Lila Rose used it the other day on her podcast). What’s more, the phrase CSAM is vague, clinical, and abstract. It tends to sanitize the horrific crime committed against children. Because its scope is unclear, it can also allow for the depiction of unreal children to satisfy the urges of pedophiles. Additionally, it tends to hide the overlap between child exploitation and what many might consider the acceptable mainstream porn industry.

What’s more, the phrase CSAM is vague, clinical, and abstract. It tends to sanitize the horrific crime committed against children.Tweet This

We on the right tend to fight the language wars poorly. How trippingly we now use “gay” instead of “homosexual.” Consider, too, “reproductive health,” “medical aid in dying,” “sex work.” It is not as if we have not fought these terms, but the other side has won so easily. In this case, we do not have to surrender a phrase that is cold, hard, and clear. CSAM may be trendy, but “child porn” is what we ought to be using.

Author

Orthodox. Faithful. Free.

Sign up to get Crisis articles delivered to your inbox daily

Email subscribe inline (#4)

Join the Conversation

Comments are a benefit for financial supporters of Crisis. If you are a monthly or annual supporter, please login to comment. A Crisis account has been created for you using the email address you used to donate.

Donate

There are no comments yet.

Editor's picks

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00
Share to...