In the wake of the Republican implosion in the Nov. 3 midterms, expect the “Catholic Left” to come out—ahead of the upcoming USCCB’s Plenary Assembly in Baltimore Nov. 16-19—with demands the bishops “acknowledge” they should be at some turning point and need to fall in line with what it calls “the obvious way forward.” Most basically, that means giving up the “culture warrior approach” and embracing “the more pastoral and less worldly” approach supposedly of Popes Francis and Leo. No doubt, they take that also to mean giving up abortion as the “preeminent issue” in our social justice outreach and curling up in the Bernardin-Cupich “seamy seamless garment” of life.
No thanks. No way.
As a result of Tuesday’s elections, significant numbers of the unborn are going to die thanks to the ascendance of Democratic politicians. I am hopeful the damage at the federal level can be contained by Republican Senate filibuster (if it isn’t abolished) and/or presidential veto. But in the states—where Democrats now hold the majority of governorships for the first time since 2010—the outlook is more dire.
As a result of Tuesday’s elections, significant numbers of the unborn are going to die thanks to the ascendance of Democratic politicians.Tweet ThisLet’s take Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania (like 1970s Massachusetts) was once a pro-life beacon. With a Democratic trifecta headed to Harrisburg, decades of valuable pro-life gains in the Keystone State may be eviscerated and the next state constitutional amendment guaranteeing abortion-on-demand throughout pregnancy could be on its way to Pennsylvania voters in 2029. Why?
Once upon a time, working-class Pennsylvania had working-class Democrats who respected life. Many of Pennsylvania’s protections of the unborn owe to Robert Casey, Sr., the governor who became a Democratic pariah because of his pro-life stance. He was supported by pro-life Democrats in the state legislature, like Westmoreland County’s Tommy Tangretti. Democratic Congressmen like Austin Murphy, Joseph Gaydos, and Joshua Eilberg were Human Life Amendment cosponsors in the House.
With Illinois Democrat Dan Lipinski’s primary defeat in Illinois in 2020, his party became hostile territory to anybody who embraced Vatican II’s teaching that abortion and infanticide are “unspeakable crimes” against God and man. They want to shout them. From the rooftops.
A nominally Catholic governor in Massachusetts from the party that spent four years lecturing Americans about “democracy” decided to declare an “emergency” to promulgate a radically pro-abortion bill she helped steer through the Legislature, despite the fact that ordinary Massachusetts men and women collected sufficient signatures to put the repeal of the proposed statute on the ballot. At least Massachusetts’ bishops decided to condemn the action. It would be better if they drew a line in the sand and excommunicated her. Sorry, but I’m not going to “accompany” Maura Healey in her “discernment” along her pro-abortion trek to the nearest Planned Parenthood clinic while she tries to put pro-life pregnancy centers out of business.
There is a war over life. The only problem is that the Catholic Left has hoisted white flags above its doors.
There is a war over life. The only problem is that the Catholic Left has hoisted white flags above its doors.Tweet ThisThe flabby defense of life we’ve seen for decades from the Catholic Left may now find its Protestant counterpart. The New York Times calls them the “Matthew 25” group, numbering among itself people like Texas Senator-elect James Talarico and Kansas Senator-elect Adam Hamilton. Their argument: Christian politics should be measured by the criteria of the Last Judgment scene in Matthew 25:31-46, where what matters are the food programs, the clothing banks, the hospitable jails, and likely all manner of social welfare programming that, at the same time, allows a polite circumvention of the slaughter of the unborn.
Hamilton, a Methodist pastor, has even invented his own variant of the Catholic seamless garment: “pro-life with a heavy heart,” i.e., he is personally opposed to abortion but I guess impersonally won’t do anything about it other than wring his hands. At least that’s better than Talarico’s creative exegesis that finds no basis for pro-life views in the New Testament.
It took Protestant Evangelicals a good decade before they really jumped aboard the pro-life ship, as Daniel Williams pointed out in Abortion and America’s Churches. The 1970s right-to-life movement had a distinctly Catholic flavor. Protestants kept it at arm’s length for two reasons: the Protestant Left was making its peace with abortion (and much of the modern sexual Zeitgeist) while Evangelicals were hoping Jimmy Carter in the White House might staunch the moral rot they were observing but not yet ready to find common cause with Catholics about. When they discovered that four years of Carter had really done nothing to tackle what they saw as American moral decline, Evangelicals cautiously began recognizing they might have had more in common morally with the Catholics they deplored in 1960 as papist puppets than with their fellow Protestants. And now, it looks like the Protestant Left will give them Bernardin Lite.
Evangelicals cautiously began recognizing they might have had more in common morally with the Catholics they deplored in 1960 as papist puppets than with their fellow Protestants.Tweet ThisIn a recent conversation with a pro-life state right-to-life leader, he told me we needed to end the strange silence that has stopped talking about the unborn child. We talk about the mother and the difficult circumstances of some pregnancies, but we have progressively stopped talking about how babies die (the pictures largely went away long ago as too gory). How many people know that the abortion-pill wonder drugs mifepristone and misoprostol actually work by starving the developing child? By cutting him off from the uterine lining, they leave the embryo unable to draw sustenance or oxygen from his mother. In ordinary terms (pro-abortionists hate ordinary terms) it means that embryo is starved and suffocated.
No, Gavin Newsom is not “pro-life” because he commuted the capital sentences of hundreds of murderers. No, Dick Durbin is not a model “pro-life” Catholic because he aligns with some bishops’ views on immigration. No, Mario Cuomo was not the Angelic Doctor for politicians.
If there’s any message from the 2026 midterms, it is that the war over life is going to get hotter. I predict the ascendance of Democratic trifectas in more states will lead to expansion of physician-assisted suicide as the next frontier in that battle. If Vatican II is truly the lodestar that so many—including in the Vatican—insist it is, then the Council’s clear language about abortion and infanticide, crimes which have grown exponentially since Gaudium et spes (#51) was 61 years ago, should be front and center. This is the time for the bishops to grow spines (and other body parts) and unfurl a pro-life “banner of bold, unmistakable colors with no pale pastel shades.”
There are no comments yet.