The Wall Street Journal reported last week that an unlikely coalition of Christian and Jewish private schools and universities has emerged in opposition to a proposal issued in September by the U.S. Treasury Department titled “Racial Nondiscrimination in Private Schools,” which would allow the government to revoke the tax-exempt status of schools engaging in racial preferences. Although the policy targets race-based preferences, its implications extend far beyond tax policy. For Catholics, the central question concerns the limits of state authority and the Church’s liberty to govern her schools, universities, and other apostolates according to her mission.
The government’s immediate objective is not difficult to understand. Since the civil rights era, American law has rejected racial discrimination in education, as reflected in the Supreme Court’s decision in Bob Jones University v. United States (1983). The Court held that Bob Jones University, a private Christian institution in South Carolina that had excluded Black applicants until 1971 and later maintained policies banning interracial marriage and dating among students according to its fundamentalist interpretation of Scripture, was not entitled to tax-exempt status. The decision rested on the government’s compelling interest in eradicating such practices from education.
The significance of the Treasury’s proposal lies less in what it seeks to achieve in this case than in the broader political and legal movement to which it belongs. Although directed at racial preferences rather than issues of sexual orientation or gender identity, it forms part of a broader effort to dismantle the woke policies associated with DEI (diversity, equity, and inclusion), which have become deeply entrenched in many American institutions. The initiative emerges in the wake of Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard College (2023), the landmark Supreme Court decision that ended race-conscious admissions, and amid a broader movement in many states to restrict DEI initiatives in higher education. DEI itself has expanded beyond equal treatment under the law to encompass broader claims about identity, equity, and social justice.
DEI itself has expanded beyond equal treatment under the law to encompass broader claims about identity, equity, and social justice.Tweet ThisFor Catholic institutions, however, the more fundamental concern is the precedent that may be set if the state gains greater power to determine which beliefs and practices are compatible with its understanding of equality.
Opposition to racial injustice does not require Catholics to embrace every ideology that has been associated with DEI. The Church, in fact, has a sacred duty to defend both the equal dignity of every human person and the objective moral order established by God, and therefore cannot affirm ideological claims regarding sexuality, gender, or marriage that are contrary to Sacred Scripture, Natural Law, and the perennial teaching of the Catholic faith. The freedom to uphold these truths is essential if Catholic institutions are to remain authentically Catholic.
There is quite a paradox in the public promotion of certain LGBTQ+ initiatives by some Catholics, but that is an altogether different situation from the Church’s absolute rejection of racial segregation and inequality. The two issues must not be confused. The Church can be against racial injustice and yet still hold that social inclusion can never be at the expense of revealed truth. True charity is not separable from the truth about man and woman made in the image and likeness of God (Genesis 1:27).
The government’s proposal itself recognizes an important part of this principle. It expressly permits religious schools to maintain their religious mission, curriculum, and programs of worship, and it allows policies based upon genuine religious affiliation. That is welcome. Indeed, a Catholic school cannot be genuinely Catholic if the state possesses the authority to dictate its religious identity.
Indeed, a Catholic school cannot be genuinely Catholic if the state possesses the authority to dictate its religious identity.Tweet ThisBut the larger concern remains: how secure is that liberty when the state can determine whether an institution’s policies violate a “fundamental public policy” and thereby threaten its tax-exempt status? The stakes become even higher in light of the new democratic socialists joining the next Congress in January.
Recent experience makes the point. Under the Biden administration, gender policies were deeply embedded in the federal bureaucracy through executive orders and agency policy. For the Catholic Church, that was a direct assault on biblical anthropology and a threat to religious freedom that is guaranteed in the First Amendment. The FBI’s now-withdrawn memorandum identifying certain traditional Catholics as potentially extremist only served to exacerbate the problem.
The FBI’s now-withdrawn memorandum identifying certain traditional Catholics as potentially extremist only served to exacerbate the problem.Tweet ThisThe lesson is clear. Once the State asserts a right to determine what is and is not acceptable in the public interest, that right is unlikely to be limited to one area. A measure justified in the name of equality today could easily become a precedent for the body politic to intervene in controversial areas tomorrow.
The Catholic reaction should therefore be neither hostility to legitimate civil authority nor acquiescence to every claim made in the name of equality. It should be to defend the proper distinction between the temporal jurisdiction of the State and the liberty of the Church to carry out her mission.
Ultimately, the central concern is whether Catholic institutions will be allowed to remain Catholic. The State has a legitimate role in the temporal sphere and is expected to combat genuine racial discrimination. It, however, has no authority over truths that precede its existence. The dignity of the human person, the nature of marriage—between male and female—the mission of the Church, and the moral law are rooted in the order of creation and ultimately in God. The U.S. Treasury’s proposal therefore raises a question that is not merely legal nor political: whether a free society still has the courage to acknowledge the limits of the State’s power and whether the Church is free to carry out her mission without being required to conform to the dictates of the day.
There are no comments yet.