Why Won’t Bishops Say Muslims Need Christ?

A cardinal says the Church is “not there to convert.” Italy’s bishops teach Islam from fact sheets co-written with Muslim scholars. Why won’t bishops say Muslims need Christ? Eric Sammons on Vesco, Cardinal Sarah, and Dominus Iesus.

PUBLISHED ON

November 3, 2026

Crisis Point
Crisis Point
Why Won't Bishops Say Muslims Need Christ?
Loading
/

Eric Sammons looks at Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco’s doubling down and the persecution-law context of Algeria, the CEI/PISAI Islam fact sheets, Cardinal Robert Sarah’s warning (“Wake up. Islam is a danger.”), and Abdul El-Sayed’s comparison of sharia to Catholic canon law. Eric also tells his own story: how the USCCB’s interreligious office reviewed a Catholic high school textbook and warned that its treatment of Islam “smacks of proselytism, which would really offend the Muslims.” Finally, what the Church actually teaches in Nostra Aetate, the Catechism, and Dominus Iesus: esteem for Muslims and the duty to proclaim “the necessity of conversion to Jesus Christ” are not opposites.

📖 Deadly Indifference: https://ericsammons.com/product/deadly-indifference/

📖 The Catholic Guide to Artificial Intelligence: https://ericsammons.com/product/the-catholic-guide-to-artificial-intelligence/

Thumbnail photo credits:
• Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco: Agenzia Fides, CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), via Wikimedia Commons
• Cardinal Robert Sarah: François-Régis Salefran, CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), via Wikimedia Commons

Subscribe to Crisis Point and read more at https://crisismagazine.com

Recent Episodes

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00